The consensus is the same... ride what you like and what feels good.  
But the way to compare it to kiteboarding on water is that the skis are the surfboard while the snowboard is the twin-tip.  Different tools to enjoy different conditions.  And everything works... from straight skis of the 80's era to almost every other shape and size.  I switch off 50/50 between skis and boards.  I've been on frozen lakes where skis had better edge control, and miles back from the road where the skins and touring ability of skis are essential (along with a snowkite that packs down small also).  Split boards can compensate slightly for that, along with a pair of snowshoes.  Skis have a huge advantage for lightwind riding and for hitting higher speeds if thats your bag.  
I've had many favorites from directional snowboards to 179 Twin tips to skis of all sizes to my latest favorite, the reverse camber style board...
http://www.TwistedKiteboards.comUse both, use whats in your garage, use what is fun to ride.  
Windzup,
Brian Schenck
BTW - Pow is around the corner!